Why true crime podcasts affect your sleep more than horror films according to researchers

January 29, 2026

The popularity of true crime podcasts has surged in recent years, mesmerizing listeners with tales of real-life mysteries and murders. Surprisingly, many people find that these podcasts can be more soothing than terror-inducing horror films, affecting their sleep quality in unexpected ways. Research indicates that the intimate, often narrative-driven format of podcasts creates a unique psychological environment that can help listeners process their fears, albeit with a mix of anxiety and fascination. But how exactly do these chilling tales lull people into a restful slumber?

Researchers have uncovered that the storytelling techniques used in true crime podcasts allow listeners to engage with their fears in a controlled manner. The suspense and thrill create a cognitive challenge, igniting curiosity while providing distance from the actual dangers presented in the stories. This contrasts sharply with the visceral shock of horror films, where sudden scares can lead to heightened fear responses and increased sleep disruption. Listeners can thus find a sense of safety in experiencing anxiety about a crime, distancing real-life threats from their nightly routine.

How True Crime Podcasts Foster Relaxation

True crime podcasts allow listeners to explore dark narratives while often feeling part of a larger community. This immersive experience can lower anxiety levels; by confronting fears, listeners may find solace in the knowledge that they are not alone in their concerns. The engaging narrative serves as a distraction from daily stressors, helping listeners unwind before bed.

The Psychological Impact of Media Consumption

Delving into gruesome tales may not resonate with everyone, but for many, the therapeutic aspect of true crime is compelling. As listeners navigate these narratives, they often glean insights into survival mechanisms, thereby turning fear into empowerment. This process can enhance their perception of safety in daily life, allowing them to sleep more soundly.

Why Horror Films Can Disrupt Sleep

In contrast, horror films often rely on shock tactics and sudden scares, which can lead to increased heart rates and anxiety. As viewers are thrust into an unpredictable world of terror, they might experience heightened tension that lingers long after the credits roll. Such emotional states are less conducive to peaceful rest, resulting in a fragile sleep environment.

Women and Their Fascination with True Crime

Interestingly, studies show that women are statistically more drawn to true crime stories. Research suggests that women resonate with these narratives as they find comfort in learning about potential dangers and effective responses to them. This educational aspect can serve as a form of empowerment, making the listening experience not just entertaining but also psychologically meaningful.